Quantcast

NEW Reviews Beta Feedback

  • Print

Oki Printing Solutions C5800LDN

80

Good

  • Pros
  • Fast print speeds
  • Good paper handling
  • Cons
  • Text output was a little light
  • Banding and dithering on color graphics
thumb 1 thumb 2

Oki Printing Solutions C5800LDN Review

by Paul Jasper

The C5800Ldn delivers high-quality text at a fast pace, and offers good paper capacity and a duplexer at an attractive price.

The $799 Oki Printing Solutions C5800Ldn looks like other models we've seen from the company, but it offers faster, more economical printing. It comes with a built-in duplexer for double-sided printing, which costs $320 as an option for other members of the family.

The C5800Ldn uses your PC's processor to render its pages from the Windows GDI. Printers that support PCL or PostScript use their own memory and processor for this task, and tend to be faster than Windows GDI-based models.

Nonetheless, in our tests, this printer was very fast, outputting 19.5 pages per minute for text documents and 6.1 ppm for color graphics. The text on our monochrome text pages seemed a bit light, but the characters were crisp and sharp. Our line art sample appeared lighter than its competitors, too, perhaps in part because its lines were so thin and precise. In spite of this precision, we observed some vertical banding and graininess in blocks of very close lines.

Our grayscale image had the opposite problem: This image was too dark to show good shadow detail and was marred by a magenta cast. The shiny ink made our color graphics test look almost photographic, but strong dithering patterns hurt the effect. With the driver adjusted for higher-quality printing on glossy paper, the color image fared no better, showing dark and unnatural colors scored horizontally and vertically by narrow banding.

This model's main paper drawer has a 300-sheet capacity. The fold-down multipurpose feeder tray can hold 100 additional sheets of paper, though Oki advises you to stack no more than ten envelopes at a time. You can add an 530-sheet drawer for a steep $456 to raise the maximum paper capacity to 930 sheets; 250 sheets collect face down in the output bin on top of the unit. The face-up stacker that folds down from the rear of the printer accommodates another 100 sheets and provides a straight path for envelopes and other heavy media.

The C5800Ldn ships with four toner cartridges, each rated for 2000 pages. Its horizontal paper path contributes to its large footprint (16.7 by 22.1 by 13.6 inches), though it doesn't tower above the desk like its vertical rivals). Its horizontal path design simplifies replacing the ink cartridges. The inks are available in more-economical 5000-page capacities, priced at $90 for black and $144 for each of the three colors. You also need to replace the black drum (reasonably priced at $68) and three color drums ($74 each) every 20,000 pages. The warranty covers replacement of the fuser unit and transfer belt, each rated for 60,000 pages. The estimated per-page costs are 2.1 cents for monochrome and 11.9 cents for color.

Good paper handling, fast print speeds, and reasonable page costs make this color laser a good fit for busy offices.

Paul Jasper

User Reviews for Oki Printing Solutions C5800LDN

  • Reviewed by: cymbalzzz

    Duration of ownership: 1 Year

    Strengths: Very fast output. Waxy-based toner is very attractive.

    Weaknesses: Too many to list here. See overall evaluation.

    Overall Evaluation: As soon as I finish the last toner cartridges on this printer, out to the trash it goes, and believe me, that can't happen soon enough. I had have total quality problems with this machine from the beginning. Was mine a lemon? Maybe so. I'd like to think so. Color density/matching has been a nightmare from the beginning, despite many, many tens of hours attempting to tweak, adjust, etc. Customer service was of no help in this department. Shortly after ownership, the unit developed a gouge in the fuser. Oki sent me a new fuser. It was not long after that (and still to today) that I have apparently yet again a fuser problem that places a small mark in all printing three times on the page, along with a solid line down the page on solid color prints. The printer counter is bizarre. I sent an indepth email to tech support regarding detailed statistics I had gathered on page counts. After running exactly 75 copies of a fairly simple flyer, the tray 1 Count increased by 328 pages; the Color Page Count increased by 656 pages; and the Y Toner Life and K Toner life went down by 20%. Why does 75 pages = 328 pages or 656 pages? At this rate of toner consumption, you would only be able to print 375 copies on 4 full cartridges = $302.68? I never got an answer from Okidata other than a canned answer to call them to discuss, and that - yes - I would have to reinvent the wheel in my telephone call, because my lengthy and detailed email would not be available to anyone prior to my calling. I am embarrassed to used this printer to produce publications in instances where they will reflect on my professionalism. I have to apologize constantly to those who unfortunately have to be the recipient of documents printed on this machine. This has been an expensive mistake in purchasing this printer. Hopefully I can be rid of it soon!!!

  • Reviewed by: fdwhite628

    Duration of ownership: 14 Months

    Strengths: excellent color and easy to use

    Weaknesses: not compatibile with Window's Vista

    Overall Evaluation:

Printers Playing in PCW Video

Latest Printers News, Reviews, How-To's